How to Stencil a Decorative Tray: DIY Painted Tray

This post may contain affiliate links. Please see our full Disclosure Policy for details.

Looking to add a personalized touch to your home decor? One of the easiest ways to elevate your space is by creating a DIY stenciled decorative tray. Whether you’re using it to serve drinks, organize essentials, or simply for display, a hand-painted tray adds charm and style.

Stencils are popular for painting walls and floors on larger scale but that doesn’t mean stencils are not useful for smaller projects. In this beginner-friendly tutorial, you’ll learn how to stencil a tray, what paints to use, and design ideas that pop!

Why Stencil a Tray?

Stenciling offers a professional-looking finish without requiring advanced painting skills. It’s one of the top searched DIY tray decorating ideas because:

It’s budget-friendly
Stencils allow for intricate designs without freehand painting
You can reuse old trays or inexpensive ones from thrift stores

Step-by-Step: How to Stencil a Tray

Materials

To get started with your painted tray DIY, gather the following materials:

A wooden, metal, or plastic tray (any shape works)
Acrylic paint or chalk paint (your choice of base and accent colors)
Stencil of your choice (floral, geometric, boho, or text)
Painter’s tape
Stencil brush or foam dabber
Sandpaper (optional for prepping wood)
Clear sealer (spray or brush-on)
Drop cloth or newspaper to protect your work surface

1. Prep the Tray

Start by cleaning your tray with a damp cloth. If it’s wooden or glossy, lightly sand the surface to help the paint adhere better. Wipe away dust before painting.

2. Paint the Base Coat

Apply your chosen base color using a foam brush or roller. Let it dry completely. You can do two coats if needed for full coverage. Since my tray’s base was already white I spray paint the sides by placing newspaper on the tray’s surface to keep it save from paint.

Popular tray base color ideas: white, navy, sage green, black, blush pink, or wood-stain finish.

3. Secure the Stencil

Once dry, tape your stencil in place using painter’s tape. Make sure it’s flat and centered. Use light adhesive spray for large or intricate stencils to prevent paint bleed.

4. Apply Paint to the Stencil

Dip your stencil brush or foam dabber in paint, then dab off the excess on a paper towel. Dab the paint on stencil at right angel 90° not sideways.

Use an up-and-down dabbing motion (not brushing) to prevent bleeding under the stencil.

Pro tip: Less paint = cleaner stencil lines!

5. Peel and Reveal

Carefully lift the stencil while the paint is still wet. Let the design dry fully before handling or sealing.

6. Seal for Durability

To protect your tray, especially if it will be used for serving, apply a clear sealer. Choose a matte, satin, or glossy finish depending on your look. I applied two layers of mod podge letting each dry before applying the next.